![]() |
||
To comment scroll to the bottom of the entry. Your e-mail address and URL are optional fields.
2006 05 05
Mark Kingwell Writes on The Empire State Building - Part 3
![]() But even absent such aesthetic rehabilitation, the Empire State would be superior in meaning, the distinctive image of mythic New York: the New York of film and fiction, beckoning and false, corrupted and sometimes corrupting, but irresistible for all that. The building is-obviously-a tower, indeed the central tower of New York. Thus it functions, as the modernist master Robert A.M. Stern once said, as “the lighthouse of Manhattan.’’ But like all towers, it is no mere structure or landmark. A tower speaks of and to the human ambition for transcendence, that restless desire to transcend what the Futurist theorist Emilio Filippo Tommaso Marinetti called “the vile earth.’’ The paradox of the tower, any tower, is that it stands fixed to the ground even as it stretches up and tries, somehow, to achieve liftoff. The Empire State is not Futurist in design, nor is it explicitly utopian. Indeed, its workaday offices and no-nonsense design are deliberately utilitarian in conception. Most people who visit the building pay no attention to its often under-rented interior, a kind of urban time machine filled with diamond merchants, insurance companies and private investigators, among many, many others. Nevertheless, with its machine-made grace, the Empire State Building towers above the island grid and fixes the scene. Standing at the center of Manhattan, it gathers up the city to itself and then redeploys it, out and down, to every spot from which it can be seen. Towers spring from military desire as well as spiritual urges, and the central position of the Empire State might raise, as towers do, the specter of surveillance. Especially in these Patriot Act days, one can imagine that it drapes a visual net over New York, a sort of heaven-suspended security system. And yet, the grid it overlooks is, for all its constraints, a stage of freedom and spontaneity. Its very rigidity seems to offer new invitations to liberty. The streets crush and bend and mangle their straight lines, giving way to the wonky charm of the West Village, for example, or the Battery. The Empire State, meanwhile, resolutely resists any link to the security state. Its empire is not the one of watchful eyes and foreign invasions; rather, at its summit assemble the free citizens of the world, multilingual and blessed, who ascend to gather in their views and memories, not data or evidence. The Empire State holds New York’s eight million souls together in a way the taller World Trade Center never could -- and even now, in dark memory, does not. The older building’s unlikely birth in the middle of the 1929 Crash; its defiant optimism steered by Al Smith and the financier John Jacob Raskob, those quintessential self-made men; the astonishing assembly line of steel and stone that made it the fastest mega-project the world had seen; its gathering of workers from all nations and trades-all this combines to make the Empire State the ultimate dream building. Monument and promise, folly and wonder of the world, it can be no surprise that no other tall building even dared challenge it for pre-eminence for almost half a century. We sometimes speculate about a particular feature of a city, and wonder what things would be like if it did not exist. Especially because of what happened to those taller buildings downtown, the answer in the case of the Empire State Building is clear. Like our ideas of God and happiness, if the Empire State Building did not exist in the New York skyline, we would have to invent it. [email this story] Posted by M. Kingwell on 05/05 at 11:25 AM
Next entry: On The Inside - The Don Jail Previous entry: Artist's Talk - Archive Inc. |
Toronto News
MESH Cities
M00o93H7pQ09L8X1t49cHY01Z5j4TT91fGfr
Spacing
M10o93H7pQ09L8X1t49cHY01Z5j4TT91fGfr
Blogto.com
M20o93H7pQ09L8X1t49cHY01Z5j4TT91fGfr
Torontoist.com
M30o93H7pQ09L8X1t49cHY01Z5j4TT91fGfr
Toronto Galleries
Archives of Ontario
R.C. Archdiocese of Toronto Art Gallery of Mississauga Art Gallery of Ontario Art Gallery of York University Art Metropole Bata Shoe Museum Black Creek Pioneer Village Blackwood Gallery Bradley Museum Creative Spirit Art Centre CBC Museum Museum of Carpets and Textiles CNE Archives Casa Loma Clint Roenisch Gallery Colborne Lodge Collections and Conservation Centre David Dunlap Observatory Gallery TPW Glendon Gallery Goethe-Institute Grange HVACR Heritage Centre Canada Historic Fort York Hockey Hall of Fame The Law Society MacKenzie House Market Gallery Mercer Union Ontario Association of Art Galleries Ontario Crafts Council Ontario Science Centre Royal Canadian Military Institute Royal Ontario Museum Ryerson Polytechnical University Archives Scarborough Historical Museum Sharon Temple Museum Spadina Museum Textile Museum of Canada Thomas Fisher Rare Book Toronto Aerospace Museum Toronto Writers Centre YYZ Artists' Outlet York Museum |
Related Links
Toronto Stories by
Stats
Toronto Links
Your Opinions
Other Blogs
News Sources
Syndicate
|